Casey's General Stores Inc CASY

Morningstar Rating

Company Report

Casey's Looks Poised to Continue Consolidating the Convenience Store Industry in the Rural Midwest

Despite operating in a highly fragmented convenience store industry where competition is omnipresent and barriers to entry are minimal, Casey’s financial performance continues to be admirable. As gasoline demand in the United States has shown signs of flattening over the past decade and store operating costs continue to rise, independent convenience store operators have raised fuel margins to compensate. As a result, Casey’s has enjoyed a significant uptick in profitability as its fuel margins expanded from about 20 cents per gallon in 2019 to about 40 cents in fiscal 2024. Due to its significant size and scale relative to smaller independent convenience stores, we think the firm is poised to continue reaping the benefits of a structurally higher fuel margin environment.

Price vs Fair Value

CASY is trading at a 354% premium.
Price
$366.65
Fair Value
$556.00
Uncertainty
Medium
1-Star Price
$225.79
5-Star Price
$749.20
Economic Moat
Dzmzhs
Capital Allocation
Pjfctcvfm

Bulls Say, Bears Say

Bulls

As independent convenience store operators raise fuel margins to compensate for flattening gasoline demand and rising costs, Casey’s should reap the benefits of higher fuel profits.

Bears

Casey’s in-store merchandise and prepared food is undifferentiated and puts it into competition with dollar stores, grocery stores, and quick-service restaurants.

News

Trading Information

Previous Close Price
Day Range
52-Week Range
Bid/Ask
/
Market Cap
Volume/Avg
/

Key Statistics

Price/Earnings (Normalized)
26.27
Price/Sales
0.91
Dividend Yield (Trailing)
0.49%
Dividend Yield (Forward)
0.49%
Total Yield
1.05%

Company Profile

Casey’s serves as the nation’s third-largest convenience store chain with its more than 2,600 locations primarily positioned in the Midwest United States. About half of Casey’s stores are located in rural towns with populations under 5,000. While fueling stations serve as a key traffic driver, about two thirds of the company’s gross profit stems from in-store sales of grocery items, prepared meals, and general merchandise. Casey’s owns more than 90% of its stores and operates most of its warehousing and distribution processes internally.
Sector
Consumer Cyclical
Industry
Specialty Retail
Stock Style Box
Mid Core
Total Number of Employees
45,359

Competitors

Valuation

Metric
CASY
MUSA
3382
Price/Earnings (Normalized)
26.2719.266.48
Price/Book Value
4.2212.061.49
Price/Sales
0.910.480.50
Price/Cash Flow
13.8712.986.45
Price/Earnings
CASY
MUSA
3382

Financial Strength

Metric
CASY
MUSA
3382
Quick Ratio
0.420.490.61
Current Ratio
0.840.840.91
Interest Coverage
13.218.066.15
Quick Ratio
CASY
MUSA
3382

Profitability

Metric
CASY
MUSA
3382
Return on Assets (Normalized)
8.82%12.27%4.49%
Return on Equity (Normalized)
18.68%65.95%13.15%
Return on Invested Capital (Normalized)
12.94%19.76%6.59%
Return on Assets
CASY
MUSA
3382

Specialty Retail Industry Comparables

1-Day Chart
Name
Price
Morningstar Rating for Stocks
Capital Allocation
Economic Moat
Market Cap
O'Reilly Automotive Inc
ORLY
GrtckzghvrXhq$66.7 Bil
AutoZone Inc
AZO
DlkgtfpcqnYnnm$51.9 Bil
Tractor Supply Co
TSCO
LmzkdslhdgSstz$31.5 Bil
Best Buy Co Inc
BBY
TzpysrtKccsnlt$21.1 Bil
Williams-Sonoma Inc
WSM
SpwxbdqqGycjt$19.2 Bil
Ulta Beauty Inc
ULTA
YvnjnbrzMqcpnmb$17.6 Bil
Dick's Sporting Goods Inc
DKS
BmdxmyjxqLljgdv$16.9 Bil
Murphy USA Inc
MUSA
QgpwlqphCxqqtn$9.8 Bil
Bath & Body Works Inc
BBWI
CzfrnylpPfnfk$6.5 Bil

Sponsor Center