Mattel Earnings: Successful Holiday Season Contingent on Continued Momentum in Barbie and Wheels
Narrow-moat Mattel’s MAT third-quarter sales results were in line with our $1.9 billion forecast, as Barbie and Hot Wheels (together 46% of gross billings) again carried the load, with worldwide gross billings 16% and 22% higher, respectively. Fisher-Price (1% decline), American Girl (down 13%) and the challenger brands (up 1%) continue to weigh on sales performance, although we note all three had sales that improved sequentially. On the bottom line, adjusted EPS of $1.08 beat our estimate by more than $0.20, largely attributable to a 51% gross margin, which was up 270 basis points, benefiting from mix (170 basis points, helped by Barbie-related sales), price (140), and cost savings initiatives (130) partially offset by fixed costs. With some operating leverage on 9% sales growth, Mattel was able to achieve a 26% operating margin, a high-water mark.
We had expected the back half of 2023 to present well, given Mattel was lapping an 11% decline in the sales in the second half of 2022, as prior-year shipments pulled forward to the first half in response to supply chain constraints. Mattel reiterated flat sales guidance for 2023, implying a roughly 16% increase in sales could be captured in the firm’s fourth quarter—in line with our outlook. Furthermore, we had already projected EPS of $1.17 for fiscal 2023—in line with the firm’s updated outlook for EPS of $1.15-$1.25. However, considering the third quarter’s outperformance, we plan to reduce our EPS forecast to around $0.30 from $0.50 and see this specific issue as the culprit sending shares down 7% after hours. We surmise most of this compression stems from higher incentive compensation in the fourth quarter, rather than a systemic increase in the enterprise’s expense structure. As such, we don’t plan to materially alter our $25 fair value estimate and view shares as attractive given the relatively conservative projections for 3% sales growth and midteen operating margins over the long run that underlie our valuation.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.